We Took on the Blemishes, You Get the Glow: 5 Best Face Washes in 2025

We Took on the Blemishes, You Get the Glow: 5 Best Face Washes in 2025

Week 6, 2025, and our skin has been through it all. We tested the so-called Best Face Washes in 2025, slathering, scrubbing, and sometimes suffering for the sake of real results. Brands throw around “dermatologist recommended,” but does that actually mean anything? Some left us with a dewy glow, others felt like rubbing detergent on our skin. If you’re tired of cleansers that don’t deliver, we’ve done the dirty work for you—these are the ones worth your money.

Lose Weight

We Scrubbed, We Foamed, We Judged: 5 Best Face Washes That Claimed to Work (But Did They?)

Are Dermatologist Recommended Face Washes Worth the Hype?

Cleansers are supposed to be the backbone of any dermatologist recommended skincare routine—the unsung heroes that set the stage for everything else we slather on afterward. And yet, time and time again, we find ourselves disappointed by face washes that actually work… until they don’t. Some strip the skin raw, others leave behind a greasy film, and a surprising number do absolutely nothing at all.

That’s where we come in. Every week, we take a hard look at the best face washes in 2025, putting them through their paces on different skin types, conditions, and concerns. No cherry-picked results, no paid promotions—just real testing with real outcomes. Our mission is simple: separate effective formulas from overhyped marketing, so you don’t waste your money on a dud.

Why Dermatologist Recommended Doesn’t Always Mean Good

A product wearing the dermatologist recommended badge sounds reassuring, right? But here’s the truth: it doesn’t always mean what you think it does. Sometimes, it just means a single dermatologist gave it a thumbs-up. Other times, it means the brand has used dermatologist-approved ingredients but in a barely effective concentration. And then there are cleansers that, despite their fancy labels, are packed with irritants, comedogenic ingredients, or unnecessary fillers.

This is why our weekly review series exists—to cut through the noise and uncover which cleansers are actually worth adding to your routine.

The Reality of Testing: No Skincare Myth Goes Unchecked

Unlike the vague, glowing praise found in paid reviews, we go beyond first impressions. A face wash may feel great on Day 1, but what happens after two weeks of use? Does it still cleanse effectively, or does it start disrupting the skin barrier?

We test every product on multiple skin types:

  • Oily skin: Does it control excess sebum without triggering overproduction?
  • Dry skin: Can it cleanse without causing flakiness or tightness?
  • Sensitive skin: Are there hidden irritants that trigger redness or breakouts?
  • Acne-prone skin: Does it contain pore-clogging ingredients, or is it truly non-comedogenic?

Because skincare isn’t one-size-fits-all, our real-world analysis helps you decide whether a cleanser is actually suited for your skin or just another marketing gimmick.

How We Test: The Criteria for Evaluating Face Washes

There’s a difference between a cleanser that feels nice and one that truly benefits your skin. A luxury face wash might give you that fancy spa feeling, but if it’s packed with irritants or lacks effective cleansing agents, it’s not worth the price tag.

To determine which cleansers earn their spot on our list, we evaluate them based on four essential factors:

Ingredient Transparency: The Good, the Bad, and the Irritating

If you’ve ever stared at a product label wondering whether glyceryl stearate, sodium lauroyl sarcosinate, or disodium EDTA belong on your face, welcome to the club. Ingredient lists can be intentionally confusing, making it easy for brands to sneak in cheap fillers, comedogenic agents, or known irritants while highlighting just one or two buzzy components (looking at you, cleansers that claim to be “infused with green tea” but list it near the bottom of the ingredient list).

We break down each face wash to analyze:

  • Active ingredients: Are they present in a high enough concentration to be effective?
  • Potential irritants: Fragrances, sulfates, drying alcohols—are they lurking in the formula?
  • Comedogenic ingredients: Do they clog pores or trigger breakouts?
  • Skin barrier support: Does it contain hydrating or soothing ingredients, or is it just another stripping cleanser?

Because not all dermatologist recommended face washes are created equal, and ingredient lists tell us far more than a marketing slogan ever could.

Application: How It Feels on the Skin

Let’s be real—if a cleanser feels bad, no one’s going to keep using it. Even the best formula in the world won’t save a product that:

  • Tugs on the skin when applied, making it difficult to spread.
  • Foams excessively, giving you that dish-soap-on-face experience.
  • Leaves behind residue, making your skin feel coated or greasy.

We assess how each cleanser applies, lathers, absorbs, and rinses, ensuring that you’re not left with that dreaded tight, dry sensation post-wash.

Performance: Short-Term vs. Long-Term Effects

Some face washes impress on day one, leaving skin feeling fresh, smooth, and soft. But what about after two weeks? Does it still cleanse effectively, or has it started causing irritation, dehydration, or breakouts?

Our performance evaluation looks at:

  • Immediate effects: Does it remove dirt, oil, and light makeup without over-stripping the skin?
  • Long-term results: Is there a noticeable improvement in skin texture, hydration, or clarity?
  • Breakout potential: Does prolonged use clog pores or trigger acne flare-ups?

Because sometimes, a face wash that feels great at first can turn into a skincare disaster after continued use.

Value for Money: Is It Worth the Price?

At the end of the day, even the most luxurious cleanser needs to justify its price tag. A $40 face wash that doesn’t outperform a $12 alternative is just a waste of money.

We compare:

  • Price per milliliter and price per ounce
  • Ingredient quality vs. cost
  • How long the product lasts with daily use

Because while some skincare reviews rave about budget-friendly cleansers, and others praise high-end luxury face washes, the truth is—price alone doesn’t determine performance.

What to Expect in This Review

This week, we tested four face washes that range from drugstore affordable to luxury high-end. Some were surprisingly effective; others were… let’s just say, not worth the hype.

In the next sections, we’ll break down each cleanser, covering:

  • Formula breakdown: What’s inside, and does it live up to the claims?
  • Application & texture: How it feels, lathers, and rinses.
  • Performance & results: Does it actually improve skin over time?
  • Who should use it? Oily, dry, sensitive, or acne-prone skin—who benefits most?
  • Price vs. value: Is it worth buying, or should you save your money?

This week’s lineup includes a mix of budget-friendly face washes, dermatologist-approved cleansers, and luxury options that claim to provide game-changing skincare results. The real question? Do they actually work, or are they just another overhyped trend?

Because after all, a good cleanser is the foundation of great skin—but a bad one can ruin everything.

In-Depth Reviews of Week 6’s Featured Face Washes

1. The Ordinary Glucoside Foaming Cleanser: Does “Gentle” Mean Effective?

The Ordinary Glucoside Foaming Cleanser is one of those products that looks deceptively simple—minimalist packaging, no-nonsense claims, and a price point that doesn’t scream luxury. But the real question is: does it actually work?

Marketed as a gentle, everyday cleanser, this face wash claims to cleanse the skin without stripping it, removing dirt, excess oil, and environmental impurities while maintaining the skin’s moisture barrier. The brand promises that with continued use, skin clarity, texture, and radiance will improve over time. It’s free from sulfates, fragrance, and essential oils, making it a supposed safe bet for sensitive skin types.

At $12.50 USD (€11.10 EUR) for 150ml, it sits comfortably in the budget-friendly category, but affordability doesn’t always equal effectiveness. We put it to the test on multiple skin types to see if it’s a true dermatologist recommended face wash or just another cleanser that over-promises and under-delivers.

A cleanser’s effectiveness is only as good as its ingredient list, and The Ordinary’s approach is refreshingly minimalistic—a tightly edited formula focused on mild, plant-derived surfactants and skin-friendly actives. But does that mean it’s good?

The Good: Non-Stripping Surfactants and Antioxidants

The backbone of this formula lies in Decyl Glucoside and Coco-Glucoside, two plant-derived surfactants known for their mild cleansing properties. These ingredients are often found in baby shampoos and gentle cleansers, meaning they cleanse without the harshness of traditional sulfates like SLS.

The inclusion of Tocopherol (Vitamin E) adds an antioxidant boost, helping to protect the skin from free radicals and pollution. While it’s not the star of the show, it’s a nice touch for those looking for skin barrier support.

The Questionable: Preservatives and Potential Irritants

While free from fragrance and sulfates, this cleanser does contain Benzyl Alcohol and Ethylhexylglycerin—preservatives that, while necessary for shelf stability, may cause irritation in sensitive skin. Some users report a mild burning sensation after prolonged use, so if you have reactive skin, this is something to consider.

Another notable inclusion is Phytic Acid, a chelating agent that enhances product stability. It’s generally well tolerated but doesn’t necessarily add much to the skin beyond keeping the formula fresh.

This cleanser doesn’t contain hydrating ingredients like glycerin or hyaluronic acid, which explains why some users find it slightly drying over time.

Application & Texture

First Impressions: Lightweight, but Slippery

The gel-like consistency is where opinions start to divide. On the one hand, it spreads effortlessly across damp skin, and a small amount goes a long way. But on the other hand, some users have likened the texture to liquid snot. Not exactly luxurious, but it does the job.

Lathering and Rinsing: A Balancing Act

Once mixed with water, it lathers into a soft, airy foam—not overly rich, but enough to provide that “clean” feeling. It rinses without residue, but for those accustomed to hydrating gel cleansers, it can feel a little too lightweight.

The issue? Some users report a tight sensation post-cleansing, especially those with dehydrated skin. While it doesn’t leave a squeaky clean feeling (which is a good thing), it also doesn’t feel particularly moisturizing.

For heavy makeup users, this cleanser is not a one-step solution. It struggles with waterproof formulas, so double cleansing is a must if you wear foundation or sunscreen daily.

 Performance & Results

Short-Term Effects: Cleans, but at What Cost?

From the first wash, the cleanser delivers what it promises—a gentle cleanse that removes daily impurities without causing immediate irritation. However, some users (particularly those with dry or sensitive skin) report that their skin feels tight after rinsing, a sign that the formula might not be hydrating enough for everyone.

Long-Term Effects: A Mixed Bag

After two weeks of consistent use, users with oily and combination skin noticed a smoother texture and slightly brighter complexion. However, those with dry or dehydrated skin found that prolonged use left their skin feeling stripped.

In terms of acne-fighting power, this cleanser doesn’t contain any actives like salicylic acid, so it doesn’t do much for breakouts. While it’s non-comedogenic, it won’t help prevent clogged pores or reduce acne over time.

Who Should Use It?

Best For:

Who Might Want to Skip It?

  • Very dry or dehydrated skin types—it may leave your skin feeling tight after prolonged use.
  • Makeup wearers—it struggles to remove waterproof products, requiring double cleansing.
  • Acne-prone skin types looking for treatment—this cleanser won’t do much to prevent breakouts.

Dr. Janine Hopkins, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist, has seen plenty of so-called “gentle” cleansers that promise to be safe for all skin types—but fail to deliver. When asked about The Ordinary Glucoside Foaming Cleanser, she acknowledges its appeal. “It’s a fragrance-free, sulfate-free option, which is great for those with sensitive skin,” she says. “But that doesn’t mean it’s hydrating or barrier-supportive.”

Many people assume that a sulfate-free cleanser automatically translates to hydrating, but Dr. Hopkins warns that not all mild surfactants are created equal. “Glucosides are gentler than sulfates, yes, but they can still be drying if the formula lacks replenishing ingredients,” she explains. “This cleanser doesn’t contain glycerin or ceramides, so for some people—especially those with dry or sensitive skin—it may still leave the skin feeling tight.”

One of the most common complaints she hears from patients using this cleanser is the post-wash sensation. “Some describe it as refreshing,” she notes, “but others say their skin feels tight or slightly dehydrated. That tells me it’s not doing enough to support the skin’s moisture barrier.”

Dr. Hopkins also raises a concern about makeup and sunscreen removal. “A single cleanse with this won’t cut it if you’re wearing foundation or water-resistant sunscreen,” she states. “I’d recommend pairing it with an oil-based cleanser first if you want a thorough cleanse without over-washing.”

When it comes to acne-prone skin, she has mixed feelings. “It’s non-comedogenic, so it won’t actively clog pores,” she says, “but it’s not doing much to prevent breakouts either. There are no acne-fighting ingredients like salicylic acid or benzoyl peroxide.” For those looking to manage acne, she suggests a targeted treatment cleanser instead. “If you’re prone to clogged pores, you need something with chemical exfoliants—otherwise, you’re just moving oil and debris around instead of properly clearing it out.”

Despite its minimalist approach, she believes the formula could be improved. “I’d like to see some humectants in here—hyaluronic acid, glycerin, even panthenol would help counteract potential dryness.” However, she acknowledges its strengths. “If you have normal to oily skin and need a basic, no-fuss cleanser, it can work. Just don’t expect it to be a one-size-fits-all solution.”

Price & Value: Does It Justify the Cost?

At $12.50 USD (€11.10 EUR) for 150ml, this cleanser is one of the more affordable options among dermatologist recommended face washes. But does that mean it’s worth the price?

Cost Breakdown

  • Price per milliliter: $0.083 USD / €0.074 EUR
  • Price per ounce: $2.46 USD / €2.20 EUR

Compared to luxury gel cleansers that retail for $30+, this is an accessible, budget-friendly option. However, considering its slightly drying effects, some users may find better alternatives at a similar price point—especially if hydration is a priority.

The Ordinary Glucoside Foaming Cleanser is a no-frills, gentle face wash that works well for oily and combination skin, but it falls short for dry and acne-prone users. While it effectively removes daily grime, it lacks hydration, and for some, it may be too basic to justify repurchasing.

If you’re looking for an affordable, minimalist cleanser, it might be worth trying—but if hydration, makeup removal, or acne prevention is your priority, there are better options out there.

2. Tatcha The Rice Wash Skin-Softening Cleanser: Luxury or Overpriced Hype?

Tatcha is known for its Japanese-inspired skincare formulations, blending tradition with modern science to create products that are as elegant as they are expensive. Their Rice Wash Skin-Softening Cleanser is marketed as a luxurious cream-based face wash designed to cleanse the skin without stripping moisture.

The brand claims that this cleanser will leave skin feeling soft, smooth, and hydrated, thanks to a blend of Japanese rice powder and botanical extracts. Formulated for dry and sensitive skin, it promises to provide gentle exfoliation while respecting the skin barrier. The formula is sulfate-free, making it a potential option for those who find foaming cleansers too harsh.

At $40.00 USD (€37.00 EUR) for 120ml, this is not a budget-friendly face wash, but Tatcha positions it as a sensorial skincare experience—a cleanser that turns an everyday routine into a self-care ritual. But is it truly a game-changer, or just another overpriced cream cleanser riding on clever marketing?

Ingredient lists don’t lie, and Tatcha leans heavily on hydrating and exfoliating elements to justify its premium price tag.

The Star Ingredient: Japanese Rice Powder

Rice powder has been a staple in Japanese skincare for centuries, revered for its ability to brighten and smooth the skin. The Rice Wash incorporates finely milled rice powder to provide mild exfoliation, helping to slough away dead skin cells without the abrasiveness of physical scrubs.

The issue? While rice powder can gently refine texture, the concentration here isn’t high enough to replace a dedicated exfoliating treatment. This means that if you’re expecting visible brightening effects, you might be left underwhelmed.

Hydration Boosters: Okinawa Algae Blend & Hyaluronic Acid

Tatcha includes Okinawa algae extract, a marine-based ingredient that claims to enhance hydration and improve skin elasticity. Paired with hyaluronic acid, the formula is meant to retain moisture and leave skin feeling soft and plump post-cleanse.

However, hydration in a cleanser is only as effective as its ability to remain on the skin. Since this is a wash-off product, these humectants don’t get long-term contact time, making their benefits short-lived compared to a serum or moisturizer.

Cleansing Agents: Mild, But Effective?

Instead of sulfates, Tatcha uses Sodium Cocoyl Glutamate and Lauryl Glucoside, which are known for being gentler surfactants that won’t strip the skin. This makes The Rice Wash a safer choice for dry and sensitive skin, but it also means that oilier skin types may find it too mild.

The Fragrance Factor

Here’s where things get tricky: this cleanser is fragranced. While the scent is light and spa-like, fragrance can be irritating for sensitive skin—which is ironic, given that the cleanser is marketed for sensitive skin types. Those prone to redness, rosacea, or fragrance-triggered irritation should proceed with caution.

Application & Texture

First Impressions: Creamy, But Not Too Heavy

Straight out of the tube, The Rice Wash has a silky, rich texture that feels instantly luxurious. Unlike traditional foaming cleansers, it spreads across the skin like a soft cream, with tiny rice particles that offer subtle exfoliation.

Lather and Rinse: Soft Foam, No Residue

Once mixed with water, the cleanser lathers into a soft, airy foam—not as dense as a foaming gel, but enough to provide a thorough cleanse. It rinses off without leaving residue, which is a major plus for those who dislike the film-like feeling that some hydrating cleansers leave behind.

Post-Wash Skin Feel: Hydrated, But Not for Everyone

While many users report that their skin feels soft and nourished post-wash, some oily skin types find it too rich, leaving a slightly coated sensation. This makes it a great winter cleanser, but those who prefer a truly lightweight finish may not love it.

Performance & Results

Short-Term Results: Immediate Softness, But No Deep Cleansing

From the first use, it’s clear that The Rice Wash is a comfort cleanser rather than a deep-cleaning powerhouse. It effectively removes light makeup, sunscreen, and daily grime, but struggles with heavier foundations or waterproof products.

Long-Term Effects: Great for Texture, But Not for Acne

With continued use, some users report smoother skin texture, likely due to the gentle exfoliating effects of rice powder. However, those with acne-prone skin find that it doesn’t do much for breakouts. Since it lacks actives like salicylic acid or benzoyl peroxide, it’s not the best choice for those dealing with frequent clogged pores.

Who Should Use It?

Best For:

  • Dry and sensitive skin types—the hydrating formula makes it less likely to strip moisture.
  • Those who enjoy sensorial skincare—the luxurious feel and spa-like scent make it an experience, not just a cleanser.
  • People looking for a mild exfoliation—the rice powder provides gentle smoothing, though results are subtle.

Who Might Want to Skip It?

  • Oily and acne-prone skin types—it might feel too rich, and it lacks acne-fighting ingredients.
  • Anyone sensitive to fragrance—while mild, it can still be irritating for reactive skin.
  • Those who need heavy-duty cleansing—it won’t remove waterproof makeup or deeply clean pores.

Dermatologist’s Perspective on Tatcha The Rice Wash Skin-Softening Cleanser

Dr. Janine Hopkins, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist, isn’t one to be easily impressed by luxurious packaging and spa-like branding. When asked about Tatcha The Rice Wash Skin-Softening Cleanser, she acknowledges its hydrating formula and gentle exfoliation but has reservations. “It’s a lovely cleanser in terms of texture and experience,” she says, “but we have to be realistic about what it can and can’t do.”

One concern she often sees with luxury cleansers is their reliance on fragrance and botanical extracts. “People assume that because something smells good and feels indulgent, it must be good for their skin,” she notes. “But fragrance—even in a well-formulated product—can still be an irritant, especially for those with rosacea or sensitive skin.”

The Rice Wash contains Japanese rice powder, a natural exfoliant known for its skin-softening properties. Dr. Hopkins agrees that rice powder can be beneficial but only in the right concentration. “It’s a nice addition, but it’s not going to replace a proper exfoliating routine,” she explains. “If you’re expecting dramatic brightening effects, you’ll probably be disappointed.”

For dry and sensitive skin types, she sees why this cleanser is appealing. “The inclusion of hyaluronic acid and Okinawa algae extract is great for moisture retention,” she says. “But at the end of the day, it’s still a wash-off product. These ingredients won’t have the same long-term impact as a leave-on serum or moisturizer.”

Dr. Hopkins is also cautious when recommending this cleanser for acne-prone or oily skin. “It’s not necessarily a bad choice,” she says, “but it lacks actives like salicylic acid or benzoyl peroxide that would actually help prevent breakouts. If you’re dealing with congestion or frequent breakouts, you might need something more targeted.”

Price & Value: Does It Justify the Cost?

At $40.00 USD (€37.00 EUR) for 120ml, this is undeniably a luxury cleanser. But is it worth the splurge?

Cost Breakdown

  • Price per milliliter: $0.33 USD / €0.31 EUR
  • Price per ounce: $9.52 USD / €8.77 EUR

While it’s cheaper than some high-end alternatives, there are hydrating cream cleansers at half the price that offer similar results.

Is It Worth It?

If you love luxurious, sensorial skincare and are willing to pay for aesthetic and experience, then yes—it’s a beautifully crafted cleanser. But if performance is your top priority, there are more affordable options that deliver equal or better results.

Lose Weight

3. The INKEY List Salicylic Acid Acne + Blackhead Cleanser: Budget-Friendly Acne Fighter or Just Another Harsh Exfoliant?

The INKEY List has built its reputation on no-fuss, ingredient-focused formulations, and its Salicylic Acid Acne + Blackhead Cleanser is no exception. Designed as an affordable exfoliating cleanser, it targets acne-prone and oily skin by using 2% salicylic acid and zinc PCA to unclog pores, reduce excess oil, and minimize blackheads.

At $13.00 USD (€12.00 EUR) for 150ml, this cleanser sits comfortably in the budget-friendly category, promising dermatologist-backed acne treatment at a fraction of the cost of premium alternatives. It markets itself as a daily-use cleanser that works to prevent breakouts before they start, but the real question is: is it a gentle acne-fighter or an overly drying, harsh exfoliant?

As always, the true power of a cleanser lies in its ingredients, and this one is packed with actives designed to combat oil and breakouts. But can it strike the right balance between effectiveness and gentleness?

The Star Ingredient: Salicylic Acid (2%)

Salicylic acid is a beta-hydroxy acid (BHA) that can penetrate deep into the pores, breaking down oil buildup, dead skin, and congestion. This makes it one of the most effective ingredients for blackheads and acne, but there’s a catch—overuse can lead to dryness and irritation, especially for those new to BHA cleansers.

For oily and acne-prone skin, this 2% concentration is right at the sweet spot—strong enough to exfoliate but not so intense that it requires dermatologist supervision. However, for sensitive or combination skin, daily use might be too much.

Zinc PCA: The Unsung Hero for Oil Control

Zinc PCA is often overlooked in acne cleansers, but it’s a powerful addition. It works by regulating sebum production, helping to keep shine and greasiness under control. It also has antimicrobial properties, meaning it may help prevent acne-causing bacteria from thriving.

For those who struggle with excess oil but aren’t necessarily breaking out all the time, this ingredient alone makes the cleanser a solid choice.

Soothing Agents: Enough to Prevent Irritation?

One of the biggest complaints about acne-focused cleansers is that they’re too aggressive, stripping the skin and leaving it red, tight, or flaky. The INKEY List attempts to counteract this with Allantoin (0.5%), an ingredient known for its soothing and anti-inflammatory properties.

Additionally, Glycerin and Betaine are included to counteract some of the potential dryness, providing a mild hydrating effect—but make no mistake, this is not a hydrating cleanser. If your skin leans dry, this won’t be enough to protect your moisture barrier.

Cleansing Agents: Are They Too Harsh?

Unlike some sulfate-heavy acne washes, this cleanser uses Cocamidopropyl Betaine and Sodium Methyl Cocoyl Taurate, which are gentler surfactants that cleanse without completely stripping moisture. However, some users with dehydrated skin have still reported a tight feeling post-wash, which suggests that while mild, it may not be suitable for daily use on sensitive skin.

Application & Texture

First Impressions: Lightweight, but Not Too Runny

The cleanser has a gel-like consistency, somewhere between a traditional foaming gel and a lightweight serum. It spreads easily on damp skin, making it simple to work into congested areas like the T-zone.

Lather and Rinse: A Refreshing Clean, But at What Cost?

Despite being sulfate-free, the cleanser does foam slightly, though not excessively. It rinses off cleanly, leaving skin feeling smooth—but some users report that it can feel a bit drying if left on for too long.

It layers well with moisturizers and acne treatments, but if you’re using retinoids or benzoyl peroxide, pairing them with this cleanser might increase irritation.

Performance & Results

 Short-Term Effects: Noticeable Oil Control, But Some Dryness

Most users report that their skin feels significantly less oily after just one use—which isn’t surprising, given the salicylic acid and zinc content. However, for those with combination or dry skin, this can translate into tightness or mild irritation, especially if used twice daily.

Long-Term Results: Effective for Acne, But Not for Hydration

After two to three weeks, many users note a visible reduction in blackheads and breakouts, particularly on the forehead, nose, and chin. The oil-balancing effects of Zinc PCA help keep greasy skin at bay, but those with dehydration-prone skin may find it too stripping over time.

It’s comparable to higher-end BHA cleansers like Paula’s Choice 2% BHA Cleanser, though not as hydrating—which may be a dealbreaker for some.

Who Should Use It?

Best For:

  • Oily and acne-prone skin—this cleanser actively reduces oil and clears pores.
  • Those struggling with blackheads—salicylic acid works deep within the pores to keep them unclogged.
  • Anyone looking for an affordable, no-fuss acne cleanser—it competes with high-end alternatives at a fraction of the price.

Who Might Want to Skip It?

  • Sensitive skin types—while mild for a BHA cleanser, it may still cause irritation.
  • Dry or dehydrated skin—this formula leans too stripping without proper hydration.
  • Those using strong acne treatments—if you’re already using retinoids or benzoyl peroxide, adding a daily 2% BHA cleanser might be too much exfoliation.

Dermatologist’s Perspective on The INKEY List Salicylic Acid Acne + Blackhead Cleanser

Dr. Janine Hopkins, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist, sees The INKEY List Salicylic Acid Acne + Blackhead Cleanser as a practical, budget-friendly option—but not one without caveats. “Salicylic acid is a gold standard for treating blackheads and breakouts,” she acknowledges. “A well-formulated 2% BHA cleanser can help keep pores clear and reduce congestion over time.”

However, she warns that acne treatment isn’t just about high percentages and strong actives. “People think that if a little exfoliation is good, more must be better,” she says. “That’s where they go wrong. Overusing a **2% salicylic acid cleanser daily—especially without proper hydration—can lead to irritation, dryness, and even a compromised skin barrier.”

While she appreciates the addition of zinc PCA, which can help regulate sebum production, she stresses that acne isn’t just about oil control. “Stripping the skin can actually cause more oil production,” she explains. “If you’re using this cleanser and your skin feels tight or flaky afterward, that’s your cue to cut back—either reduce frequency or pair it with a hydrating routine.”

For sensitive or combination skin, Dr. Hopkins recommends caution with daily use. “Some people see immediate improvement,” she says, “but others experience redness and irritation, especially if they’re using other exfoliating treatments like retinoids or benzoyl peroxide.” She advises alternating days or using it only on problem areas instead of the whole face.

Price & Value: Does It Justify the Cost?

At $13.00 USD (€12.00 EUR) for 150ml, this is one of the most affordable acne cleansers on the market.

Cost Breakdown

  • Price per milliliter: $0.087 USD / €0.080 EUR
  • Price per ounce: $2.57 USD / €2.35 EUR

Compared to luxury BHA cleansers, this offers similar effectiveness at a fraction of the price—but without the luxurious texture or added hydration.

Is It Worth It?

If you’re on a budget and need a functional, acne-fighting cleanser, it’s one of the best options at this price point. However, if hydration and gentleness are priorities, you may need to look elsewhere.

4. Paula’s Choice RESIST Perfectly Balanced Foaming Cleanser with Hyaluronic Acid: Hydrating or Just Another Overhyped Cleanser?

Paula’s Choice has built a reputation for science-backed formulations that prioritize skin health over trends, and the RESIST Perfectly Balanced Foaming Cleanser with Hyaluronic Acid fits right into that philosophy. Marketed as a hydrating, non-stripping cleanser that removes dirt, excess oil, and makeup while maintaining the skin’s natural barrier, it aims to be a daily essential for dry and sensitive skin types.

What makes it stand out? It’s packed with hydrating ingredients like hyaluronic acid and ceramides, which claim to restore moisture levels, making it an appealing option for those who struggle with dryness or a compromised skin barrier. Unlike traditional foaming cleansers that leave skin feeling tight, this one promises to cleanse without disrupting hydration.

At $22.00 USD (€20.00 EUR) for 190ml, this sits in the mid-range category—not drugstore-cheap, but also not as steeply priced as luxury brands. But does it actually live up to its claims, or is this just another hydrating cleanser with an inflated price tag?

Skincare marketing loves to throw around terms like “barrier-supporting” and “hydrating”, but a product’s actual performance comes down to its ingredients. Let’s take a look at what this cleanser really offers.

Gentle Surfactants: The Cleansing Base

Unlike many foaming cleansers that rely on harsh sulfates, Paula’s Choice uses Sodium Lauroamphoacetate and Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate—milder surfactants that effectively cleanse without over-stripping the skin.

For dry and sensitive skin types, this is a big plus since traditional foaming cleansers often lead to tightness and irritation. These surfactants help remove dirt and oil, but won’t strip away essential moisture, making this a safer option for those prone to dehydration.

Hydration Boosters: Glycerin & Hyaluronic Acid

One of the standout aspects of this cleanser is the presence of hyaluronic acid and glycerin, two powerful humectants known for their moisture-retention properties.

  • Glycerin acts as a hydration magnet, drawing moisture from the environment into the skin.
  • Hyaluronic Acid, though commonly found in serums, plays a similar role, helping to maintain hydration levels post-cleansing.

While this won’t replace a moisturizer, it helps prevent excessive water loss during cleansing, making it a great option for dry skin.

Skin Barrier Support: The Role of Ceramides

Ceramides (NP, AP, EOP) are included to help strengthen the skin barrier. These lipid molecules are naturally present in the skin and play a critical role in maintaining moisture levels.

However, since this is a rinse-off cleanser, the ceramides don’t stay on the skin long enough to provide the same benefits as they would in a moisturizer or serum. Still, their inclusion suggests a formula designed to be non-stripping, which aligns with the brand’s barrier-first philosophy.

Aloe Vera: A Soothing Addition

Aloe vera is often used for its calming and anti-inflammatory properties, making it a smart inclusion for a cleanser targeting sensitive and dry skin types. However, the concentration isn’t particularly high, so while it might offer mild soothing effects, it’s not the main highlight of the formula.

Application & Texture

First Impressions: A Lightweight Cream That Lathers Softly

Unlike traditional foaming cleansers that start as a gel, this one has a creamy, lotion-like texture. Upon contact with water, it creates a soft, airy foam, though it doesn’t produce the thick, sudsy lather that some might expect.

Rinsing and After-Feel: Soft and Hydrated

Post-rinse, skin feels clean but not tight, which is a major win for dry and sensitive skin. Some users, however, note that it doesn’t feel quite as “deep cleaning” as traditional foaming cleansers—a tradeoff for hydration.

Makeup Removal: Effective or Lacking?

One common complaint is that this cleanser doesn’t fully remove waterproof makeup, requiring a separate cleansing oil or balm beforehand. If you wear heavy foundation, SPF, or waterproof mascara, expect to double cleanse for best results.

Performance & Results

Short-Term Effects: Hydrating, But Not for Everyone

From the first wash, this cleanser delivers on its promise of hydration. Skin feels soft, refreshed, and comfortable, without the tight sensation common in foam-based cleansers.

For oily or acne-prone skin, however, the gentler formula may not feel “deep cleaning” enough, particularly for those who struggle with excess sebum.

Long-Term Benefits: A Moisture-Retaining Cleanser

With continued use, many users report smoother texture and fewer dry patches, likely due to the presence of ceramides and humectants. However, it does not contain acne-fighting ingredients, so those dealing with breakouts won’t see major improvements.

Who Should Use Paula’s Choice RESIST Perfectly Balanced Foaming Cleanser?

Best For:

  • Dry and sensitive skin types—its hydrating formula minimizes moisture loss.
  • Those looking for a barrier-friendly cleanser—ceramides help maintain skin health.
  • People who want a sulfate-free cleanser that doesn’t feel stripping.

Who Might Want to Skip It?

  • Acne-prone skin—it lacks salicylic acid or benzoyl peroxide to help prevent breakouts.
  • Oily skin types—some may find it too gentle, requiring an additional exfoliating cleanser.
  • Heavy makeup users—it may not be strong enough to remove waterproof products.

Dermatologist’s Perspective on Paula’s Choice RESIST Perfectly Balanced Foaming Cleanser

Dr. Janine Hopkins, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist, has seen countless foaming cleansers marketed as “hydrating,” only for patients to complain of tight, dry skin after using them. When asked about Paula’s Choice RESIST Perfectly Balanced Foaming Cleanser, she acknowledges its well-balanced formula but warns against expecting miracles from a face wash alone.

“This cleanser is one of the better options for dry and sensitive skin,” she says. “It’s sulfate-free and contains ceramides and hyaluronic acid, which can help maintain moisture. But let’s be clear—this isn’t a replacement for a good moisturizer.”

She often sees patients who assume that because a cleanser contains hydrating ingredients, it will actively moisturize the skin. “That’s a common misunderstanding,” she explains. “Cleansers are rinse-off products, meaning they only sit on your skin for seconds. While ingredients like glycerin and ceramides can help minimize moisture loss, they won’t provide lasting hydration.”

For those dealing with a compromised skin barrier, she sees the gentle surfactants and ceramides as a step in the right direction. “If your skin feels dry after cleansing, switching to something like this could be a good move,” she says. “But if you’re using retinoids or exfoliating acids, you’ll still need to layer on a proper barrier-repairing moisturizer afterward.”

Dr. Hopkins also points out that while this cleanser works well for dry and normal skin, it may not be the best choice for acne-prone individuals. “It doesn’t contain active ingredients that specifically target breakouts,” she explains. “If you’re struggling with acne, you’ll likely need something with salicylic acid or benzoyl peroxide in your routine.”

She also has one minor concern—the makeup removal claims. “A lot of people expect their cleanser to remove everything in one step,” she says. “But if you wear waterproof sunscreen or foundation, this may not cut it. You’ll probably need an oil-based cleanser first to break down residue.”

Price & Value: Does It Justify the Cost?

At $22.00 USD (€20.00 EUR) for 190ml, this cleanser falls into the mid-range category—not overly expensive, but not drugstore-priced either.

Cost Breakdown

  • Price per milliliter: $0.12 USD / €0.11 EUR
  • Price per ounce: $3.60 USD / €3.30 EUR

Is It Worth It?

If you’re looking for a hydrating, non-stripping cleanser that supports your skin barrier, this is a solid investment. However, if you need a deeper cleanse, acne-fighting properties, or something better at makeup removal, you might want to explore other options.

5. Innisfree Sulfate-Free Green Tea Amino Acid Cleansing Foam: A Refreshing Clean or Just Another Stripping Cleanser?

Innisfree is a brand that has long embraced natural, plant-based formulations, drawing inspiration from Jeju Island’s lush green tea fields. Their Sulfate-Free Green Tea Amino Acid Cleansing Foam is marketed as a gentle yet effective cleanser that removes impurities, excess oil, and light makeup while maintaining the skin’s natural moisture barrier.

At $12.00 USD (€11.00 EUR) for 150ml, this cleanser sits firmly in the affordable category, but the big question is: can a foaming cleanser be hydrating, or does it fall into the age-old trap of being too stripping?

A look at the ingredient list tells us whether this cleanser delivers on its promises or is just another foamy face wash with a natural label slapped on it.

The Hydration & Barrier Support Players

One of the standout claims of this cleanser is that it’s formulated to hydrate while cleansing, thanks to a blend of amino acids and ceramides.

  • Green Tea Extract (Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract) – A well-known antioxidant powerhouse that helps to protect against environmental damage and calm irritation.
  • Amino Acids (Arginine, Aspartic Acid, Glutamic Acid) – This triple amino acid complex is included to support the skin’s barrier and improve hydration levels, but given that cleansers are wash-off products, their long-term benefits are questionable.
  • Glycerin – A classic humectant that draws in moisture, which may help reduce some of the drying effects of foaming cleansers.
  • Ceramide NP – A barrier-reinforcing lipid that can help prevent water loss, though its impact may be minimal in a rinse-off formula.

The Potential Red Flags of Innisfree Sulfate-Free Green Tea Amino Acid Cleansing Foam

Despite the hydrating claims, there are a few ingredients that raise concerns—particularly for acne-prone and sensitive skin types.

  • Myristic Acid & Lauric Acid – These fatty acids double as surfactants, helping to create a rich lather. However, both are highly comedogenic, meaning they can clog pores and trigger breakouts, particularly in acne-prone individuals.
  • Fragrance – While the fresh green tea scent is pleasant, fragrance is a common irritant for those with sensitive skin.

For oily or combination skin, these ingredients may not pose major issues, but those with sensitive or acne-prone skin should tread carefully.

Application & Texture

Texture & Lather: A Little Goes a Long Way

Right out of the tube, the cleanser has a creamy, dense texture that quickly transforms into a thick, foamy lather. Users report that only a small amount is needed, making the product highly cost-effective in terms of longevity.

Scent: Pleasant, But Potentially Irritating

There’s no denying that the scent is refreshing, with its light, herbal green tea fragrance. However, as with any fragrance-infused cleanser, this could be a dealbreaker for those with easily irritated skin.

Rinse-Off Feel: Clean, But Too Clean?

After rinsing, the skin feels fresh and smooth, but some users report a slight tightness, particularly those with dry or combination skin. This suggests that despite being sulfate-free, the formula may still be too stripping for some.

Performance & Results

How Well Does Innisfree Foam Cleanse?

  • Removes dirt and excess oil efficiently, making it a solid morning cleanser for those who don’t need to remove heavy products.
  • Effectively washes off light makeup and sunscreen, but for waterproof makeup or long-wear SPF, a double cleanse is necessary.
  • Great for oily skin, but for dry or sensitive skin, it may cleanse a little too well.

Does It Actually Hydrate?

  • While the formula contains hydrating ingredients, they don’t have enough time to penetrate before being rinsed away.
  • Users with oily or normal skin report that their skin feels refreshed post-cleanse, but dry skin types may notice tightness.

Common User Complaints

  • Some users report breakouts after prolonged use, likely due to the presence of Myristic Acid and Lauric Acid, both of which are known to be comedogenic.
  • Fragrance sensitivity is another common complaint, with some users experiencing redness or irritation after use.

Comparison to Competitors

  • More affordable than luxury green tea cleansers like Tatcha’s The Rice Wash, but less hydrating.
  • Less stripping than traditional foaming cleansers, but not as moisture-retaining as a gel or cream-based face wash.

Who Should Use Innisfree Sulfate-Free Green Tea Amino Acid Cleansing Foam?

Best For:

  • Oily and combination skin types—this cleanser effectively removes excess oil without feeling too heavy.
  • Those who love a foamy cleanse—if you enjoy a rich lather, this is a great sulfate-free alternative.

Who Might Want to Skip It?

  • Acne-prone skin types—the inclusion of highly comedogenic ingredients makes this a risky choice for those prone to breakouts.
  • Very dry or sensitive skin—some users report tightness or irritation, which may make it too aggressive for compromised skin barriers.

Dermatologist’s Perspective on Innisfree Sulfate-Free Green Tea Amino Acid Cleansing Foam

Dr. Janine Hopkins, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist, sees Innisfree Sulfate-Free Green Tea Amino Acid Cleansing Foam as a decent option for oily skin, but she’s quick to caution against assuming that “sulfate-free” automatically means non-stripping.

“People hear ‘sulfate-free’ and assume a cleanser will be ultra-gentle,” she explains. “But foaming cleansers can still be drying, even without sulfates, especially when they contain fatty acids like Myristic Acid and Lauric Acid—both of which are highly comedogenic.” She warns that acne-prone individuals may actually see an increase in breakouts due to these ingredients. “It’s ironic,” she says. “A lot of my patients with acne-prone skin try this cleanser thinking the green tea will calm inflammation, but then they start noticing more clogged pores. If you’re breakout-prone, those pore-clogging agents can be a dealbreaker.”

When it comes to the hydration claims, she’s skeptical. “Yes, it contains glycerin, amino acids, and ceramides, but this is a rinse-off product,” she says. “These ingredients might help reduce moisture loss during cleansing, but they won’t actively hydrate your skin in the way a moisturizer or serum would.”

She acknowledges that green tea extract is a great antioxidant, but she doesn’t see it as a game-changer in this formula. “Green tea can help soothe inflammation and protect against oxidative stress,” she says. “But in a foaming cleanser that’s only on your skin for 30 seconds? The benefits are going to be minimal.”

For those with oily skin who love a foamy cleanse, she thinks this could work, but she’s hesitant to recommend it for dry or sensitive skin. “I’ve had patients tell me their skin feels tight after using this, which means it’s still removing too much moisture,” she explains. “If you’re using this and notice dryness, you might need to follow up with a richer moisturizer or switch to a gentler cleanser altogether.”

Price & Value: Does It Justify the Cost?

At $12.00 USD (€11.00 EUR) for 150ml, this cleanser is undeniably budget-friendly, but how does it stack up in terms of value for money?

Cost Breakdown

  • Price per milliliter: $0.08 USD / €0.073 EUR
  • Price per ounce: $2.37 USD / €2.17 EUR

Is It Worth It?

If you’re looking for an affordable, sulfate-free foaming cleanser, it’s a good deal.

If you have sensitive or acne-prone skin, there are better options available without fragrance or comedogenic ingredients.

SOURCES:

The Ordinary Glucoside Foaming Cleanser, Tatcha The Rice Wash Review | Pros & Cons – Alexa Skin, The INKEY List Salicylic Acid Cleanser & Face Wash 150ml, RESIST Perfectly Balanced Foaming Cleanser – Paula’s Choice, Sulfate-Free Green Tea Amino Acid Cleansing Foam – innisfree.

SHARE